This work addresses the critical challenge of optimal filter selection for a novel trace gas measurement device. This device uses photonic crystal filters to retrieve trace gas concentrations affected by photon and read noise. The filter selection directly influences the accuracy and precision of the gas retrieval and, therefore, is a crucial performance driver. We formulate the problem as a stochastic combinatorial optimization problem and develop a simulator modeling gas retrieval with noise. Metaheuristics representing various families of optimizers are used to minimize the retrieval error objective function. We improve the top-performing algorithms using our novel distance-driven extensions, which employ metrics on the space of filter selections. This leads to a new adaptation of the Univariate Marginal Distribution Algorithm (UMDA), called the Univariate Marginal Distribution Algorithm Unified by Probabilistic Logic Sampling driven by Distance (UMDA-U-PLS-Dist), equipped with one of the proposed distance metrics as the most efficient and robust solver among the considered ones. We apply this algorithm to obtain a diverse set of high-performing solutions and analyze them to draw general conclusions about better combinations of transmission profiles. The analysis reveals that filters with large local differences in transmission improve the device performance. Moreover, the obtained top-performing solutions show significant improvement compared to the baseline.
翻译:本研究针对一种新型痕量气体测量装置中滤波器的最优选择这一关键挑战展开。该装置利用光子晶体滤波器来反演受光子和读出噪声影响的痕量气体浓度。滤波器的选择直接影响气体反演的准确度和精密度,因此是决定装置性能的关键驱动因素。我们将该问题表述为一个随机组合优化问题,并开发了一个模拟含噪声气体反演的仿真器。我们采用代表不同优化器家族的元启发式算法来最小化反演误差目标函数。我们通过新颖的距离驱动扩展改进了性能最优的算法,这些扩展在滤波器选择空间上采用了度量方法。这催生了一种新的单变量边际分布算法(UMDA)变体,称为由距离驱动的概率逻辑采样统一的单变量边际分布算法(UMDA-U-PLS-Dist),该算法配备了所提出的距离度量之一,在所考虑的算法中成为最有效且最稳健的求解器。我们应用该算法获得了一组多样化的高性能解,并对其进行分析以得出关于透射谱更好组合的一般性结论。分析表明,具有较大局部透射差异的滤波器能提升装置性能。此外,与基线相比,所获得的最优解显示出显著的性能提升。