Nonparametric approximation of conditional expectation operators

Given the joint distribution of two random variables $X,Y$ on some second countable locally compact Hausdorff space, we investigate the statistical approximation of the $L^2$-operator defined by $[Pf](x) := \mathbb{E}[ f(Y) \mid X = x ]$ under minimal assumptions. By modifying its domain, we prove that $P$ can be arbitrarily well approximated in operator norm by Hilbert--Schmidt operators acting on a reproducing kernel Hilbert space. This fact allows to estimate $P$ uniformly by finite-rank operators over a dense subspace even when $P$ is not compact. In terms of modes of convergence, we thereby obtain the superiority of kernel-based techniques over classically used parametric projection approaches such as Galerkin methods. This also provides a novel perspective on which limiting object the nonparametric estimate of $P$ converges to. As an application, we show that these results are particularly important for a large family of spectral analysis techniques for Markov transition operators. Our investigation also gives a new asymptotic perspective on the so-called kernel conditional mean embedding, which is the theoretical foundation of a wide variety of techniques in kernel-based nonparametric inference.