Dynamics and uncertainty are essential features of real-life argumentation, and many recent studies have focused on integrating both aspects into Dung's well-known abstract Argumentation Frameworks (AFs). This paper proposes a combination of the two lines of research through a well-behaved logical tool: Dynamic Logic of Propositional Assignments (DL-PA). Our results show that the main reasoning tasks of virtually all existing formalisms qualitatively representing uncertainty about AFs are encodable in DL-PA. Moreover, the same tool is also useful for capturing dynamic structures, such as control argumentation frameworks, as well as for developing more refined forms of argumentative communication under uncertainty.
翻译:动态和不确定性是现实生活论证的基本特征,最近的许多研究侧重于将这两个方面纳入邓氏著名的抽象参数框架(AFs)中。本文件建议通过一个行为良好的逻辑工具,将两条研究线结合起来:动态假设转让逻辑(DL-PA),我们的结果表明,几乎所有现有形式主义在质量上代表AF不确定性的主要推理任务都可以在DL-PA中找到。此外,同一工具还有助于捕捉动态结构,如控制参数框架,以及开发在不确定性下更精细的论证通信形式。